Unbiased opinions?

I remember talking, several years ago, with a historian who had written several books, about searching for ‘the truth’. His contention was that all historians are searching for the plain unvarnished truth. This is patently untrue. All historians are searching for ‘their’ truth. However hard they try to be impartial it is human nature to have a ‘leaning’ towards one sort of interpretation of a ‘fact’ than another. As in the old adage ‘one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter.’ The book that had started the discussion was one by a very well-known, and very respected, writer of historical faction, about a subject that causes all sorts of arguments. (Names are not necessary here!) She obviously had decided which side she was going to come down on. There were huge amounts of evidence on each side of the debate. However, anything that disproved her theory was discounted on the grounds ‘it comes from a friend’ and anything that supported her was fine because ‘it comes from his enemies.’ Am I missing something?

During my years with the Open University I was taught how to construct an argument in an essay. Fine. But several of my tutors (not all, but a substantial amount) advised me to write my conclusion before anything else, and work towards it. I came to academia late, and my thought processes were already set to a certain extent. I start with a question, look at the evidence, and then draw conclusions based on that evidence.Now I do realise that the idea, at that stage, was to teach me to argue on either side of a debate. As someone who was a Classical Studies student (though I actually call myself an ancient historian, for good reason!) I do understand the nature of rhetoric. So, while I may not like the idea, I can understand it to a certain extent. But the idea is still somewhat foreign to me.

Along a similar track, a while ago there was an argument about what buildings were suitable for, I think, Horse guards Parade in London. Prince Charles got involved. At that time I went to an art group where one of the artists was very keen on anything ‘modern’ and was almost incoherent on the subject. Prince Charles should not have brought his considerable weight to bear. Close questioning, however, suggested that if he had been in favour……..! As an aside I must make one comment about Prince Charles. He is one of those unfortunate people who are ‘damned if they do and damned if they don’t.’ He divides opinion across the board, and is really on a hiding to nothing.

But writing the conclusion first is very much in mind at the moment! It’s Wimbledon, wahaay! And guess what, we have two – yes TWO – players into the second week. While Laura Robson is not expected to win the championship, she is put under extreme pressure for each individual match. And as for Andy Murray, he’s in the final already! After the excitements of the first week, and the loss of so many  leading players, anything less than hoisting the trophy at the end will be deemed a serious failure. The commentators making these predictions do not all have the excuse that they are true blue Brits either! But they are being paid by the very British BBC I suppose. For Andy however it is a huge pressure. Our last Wimbledon hopeful, Tim Henman, will be forever known as the player who didn’t quite make it. A serial choker.  Murray has, at least, the US Open to his name, but for a Brit it’s Wimbledon that counts. A bit like the ancient games. The winner was feted for the rest of his life. Nobody remembered who came second, except that they had seriously failed. Britain seems to have changed from a country where the taking part matters, to a country that only recognises victory. No longer the ‘nice guys’ of sport, but ready to ‘get down and dirty’ to win. Is this a good thing? I’m still not sure, but it is good to be able to cheer on someone with a realistic chance. Come on Laura! Come on Andy! But don’t feel too bad if the people who wrote the conclusion first got it wrong!

Memories

This is Marjorie Jocelyn Wilkins nee Broadbent, my mother,born 1st June 1922. Today would have been her 91st birthday. She died, aged 75, on 17th December 1997, having given up her fight against Parkinson’s Disease. And I do mean ‘given up’. She railed against it for nearly 20 years, but, in the end, it was just too much for her. We had our differences but I do still miss her terribly. Today is one of the days when I miss her more than ever.

At her funeral the minister described her as ‘single-minded to the point of obstinacy’! What he meant was that she was one of the most pig-headed people I have ever met. But she needed to be. She didn’t have the easiest of lives, but she did make the most of it. The most important thing she did, in her eyes anyway, was to join the WAAF during the war, and therefore meet my father. He was the love of her life, and, after he died in the Berlin Airlift at the tender age of 26, she never found anyone to equal him. Their wedding, in 1942, was, apparently, a joyous occasion, though you would not know it from the photographs! Aren’t they a scary lot! She loved him so much she was even jealous of me. I was the apple of my Daddy’s eye, and it was difficult for her to take. Somehow this remained for the rest of her life. My brother was always the one who did the right things – even when it was me who did them! But underneath I know she loved me, and I loved her.  As a widow with children she had many decisions to make. The most important as far as my brother and I were concerned was the one she made about our education. The people of Berlin had a fund to pay for the education of the children of the men who died saving them from starvation, and Mum decided both Graham and I should go to boarding school, and she would take a job in a school. Therefore we would not be ‘latch key’ kids, and we would have the holidays together. It could not have been easy for her. Her mother had died just a few months after my father, so she didn’t even that help. In fact she moved in to help my grandfather for a while, and then moved to a farm shared with her sister’s family. It was not until I was nearly 20 that she finally got a home of her own. Her small flat in Stratford upon Avon was her pride and joy until she had to move into assisted living due entirely to the Parkinson’s. But she was always proud of her children. My biggest regret is that she died just before I started my studies with the Open University. She would have been so thrilled with my First Class BA, and over the moon with my MA. I just wish she could have been there when I met Betty Boothroyd at Symphony Hall in Birmingham! This is one of the proudest moments in my life, and I like to think she was sitting up on her cloud feeling equally proud. Her Will, apart from the usual, asked one special thing. She wanted to be cremated, and her ashes taken to Ohlsdorf Cemetery in Hamburg to be buried with my father. 1998 was the 50th anniversary of the Berlin Airlift, and the British Berlin Airlift Association were arranging a trip for the veterans and the next of kin of the men who lost their lives. They were extremely helpful, and arranged everything – well , almost everything! German law said that, in order to take ashes into the country the box containing them had to be taken to the Embassy in London to be inspected, sealed, and a certificate issued for German Customs. Luckily my son was going to London about that time, so he offered to do the honours. He took the box in a carrier bag and boarded the train in Birmingham. A friend got on and asked if he was travelling alone. ‘No’ said son ‘I’m travelling with my grandmother!’ His trip to London included a visit to a night club, where he duly deposited the box, now sealed, in the cloakroom. Mother would have been thrilled! We were also allowed to take a marker stone, provided it was York Stone, and a standard size. My brother and I took it with us onto the plane, and put it under the seat in front of us. Flight attendant ‘This has to go in the overhead locker.’ Brother ‘I don’t think so.’ FA trying to pick it up ‘I don’t think so!’

One of the things I do miss is having to remember for both my brother and myself to buy cards and presents! Graham could only remember one birthday a year, February 10th, his own! But it is on days like this that I think about my own family. Mum and I had so many fights, and so many things that I regret I didn’t say to her when she was capable of understanding what I was saying to her. So I say now, Simon, Caroline and Nik, I love you all dearly, and your partners and children – not to forget Callum, my almost brand new Great grandson. And my only brother, Graham, with his long suffering wife Linda. Looking forward to coming to see you in a couple of months, up there in the wilds of Yorkshire!

Happy birthday Mum. I just wish you were here so I could tell you in person.

At last!

This is a Bateleur Eagle sunning itself at the Bird of Prey Centre at Batsford Arboretum. The look of ecstasy on it’s face was enough to raise the spirits after a long hard winter. How long it lasts is another matter, but, in the sunshine, I am ever the optimist! We hadn’t intended to visit Batsford, having planned to travel into Birmingham to see the John Flaxman exhibition at the IKON gallery on the last day of showing. The sight of the sunshine when we woke up, and the lack of the previously all pervading cold wind, decided us that a train journey, followed by a couple of hours indoors, was not proof against the idea of a walk in the sunshine, and a visit to the birds of prey. No contest!

It was a shame about the Flaxman exhibition though. His drawings are stunning, and the IKON is a gallery well worth supporting. Free entry and a really good cafe does go a long way! But the walk in the sunshine was much healthier for our bodies, if not for our minds. And its our bodies that need it at this time of year. We had , after all, travelled all the way to London to see the much vaunted Pompeii Exhibition at the British Museum to satisfy the mind.

This is one of my favourite exhibits, among so many. We have two dogs, and they try very hard, and very noisily, to defend the house for us! The exhibition as a whole can be summed up in just three words, ‘hot, crowded – and wonderful.’ There is far too much to take in on a single visit. I am lucky, I am a ‘Friend’ so I can ‘swipe’ in free whenever, and as often, as I like. (There was a long queue when we arrived, and their faces were a picture as we went to the front of the queue and straight in!) Our local Roman Museum group is organising a coach trip soon so I have booked a place – just on the coach, I don’t need a ticket! This is much cheaper than the train, and is effectively door to door. So I will have the opportunity to have a second go at seeing all the things I missed first time around, or was just too knackered towards the end!

This is a very poignant exhibit. Almost more than the bodies, and the babies crib. It shows how life was continuing right up to the last minute. There may be a volcano erupting, but the citizens of the town would still need bread! I’ve always maintained that the Romans were a very pragmatic and practical people, unlike the effete Greeks! I will now run for cover from my Hellenist friends!

One advantage of the much improved weather is being able to play golf without the disadvantages of so many layers of clothing! At least I can now actually swing a club properly. Not that the golf has improved much – but the enjoyment certainly has. For the first time for months I’ve actually seen the back 9 holes, and they are fantastic. Even the dreaded 12th is much improved by the filling in of the poorly placed ditch off the tee. Still find it hard (for some reason it is ALWAYS into the face of a strong wind!) but at least I can now aim straight over the pond instead of having to go right. I’m just hoping now that the weather improvements continue so, just perhaps, the golf itself will improve! Only small signs of that at the moment. I’ve just played the first round of a match play knockout competition, admittedly against the handicap secretary, and got absolutely stuffed! But it was a beautiful day, we played on until the 18th, the company was good, and I did hit a fair few good shots. Not all bad then!

There is a drawback to the good weather though! The garden is sprouting all over the place! This means lawns need mowing (Paul’s job!), beds need weeding, things need planting. Don’t misunderstand me, I love gardens, I just hate gardening. It’s the only time I really feel my age. Everything aches! Knees seize up, muscles go into spasm ……..! Ah well, there have to be some disadvantages to advancing age I suppose! Perhaps we will just decide to pave over the whole lot? Nah! Where would Gypsy and Ozzy go to dig holes and bring dirt and grass into the house? Where would the birds come to sing for us as we wake up? And where would we go to have that glass of wine in the summer evenings if all we could see was a boring pavement? The aches and pains really are worth it in the long run.

Well, that wasn’t much better!

The weather that is. March was as bad as February. Worse really because so much more is expected. There were a few glimmers of hope. There was one exceptional day when the sun shone, and the wind dropped. Fortunately it coincided with a day when Ragley Hall was open for a spring walk. It was just what a spring day should be and gave a hint of good things to come. Not a hope! By the next morning the snow was back, the overcast skies, and the feelings of deep depression. And we didn’t have it anywhere near as badly as many other parts of the country. No snowdrifts, no road closures in the immediate vicinity. Just bitter cold and overcast skies. I have a great deal of sympathy for those ex-pats struggling with the banks in  Cyprus, and  I do understand their motivation in trying to escape from the dreadful winters we seem to be having at the moment.

One big round of applause for Nigel Powell of Stratford Oaks Golf Club. Subs are due for renewal today, and, with the renewal information, we were sent an invitation to take two guests for a free 18 holes, followed by a free meal, to be taken by 31st March. I had an email from Nigel yesterday to say that, due to the bad weather, and the spasmodic course closure, this has now been extended to 30th April. Fingers crossed the weather does take a turn for the better, especially now British Summer Time has officially started. Golf in the cold is one thing, but golf in the mud is purgatory!

It’s nice to see that the Pompeii Exhibition at the British Museum has opened to glowing reviews. I love this image. Much more than the more popular picture of the baker and his wife. Perhaps it’s because I have dogs, and understand something of the instinct a dog has to defend its territory. We are Friends of the BM, which means that, even with a hugely popular exhibition like this one, we can swipe our cards at any time, and get in free. As many times as we like! So, we are travelling up to London on my birthday later in the month as a special treat. Later in the year the Friends of our local Roman Museum, where I am a volunteer, are organising a coach trip to see the exhibition. If it is as good as reviews suggest we just might beg a seat in the coach (much cheaper than the train and door to door!) for a second viewing. There is also, I understand, a live broadcast from the exhibition at local cinemas in June. This includes my local cinema. I just hope it’s not too popular. When I went into the website to try and book some tickets I was cut off at the pass. Members only at this stage. No information as to when public booking starts. I am already a Friend at the BM (worth every penny!) and a Full Member instead of the much cheaper Associate Member of the RST (undertaken to ensure tickets for this years production of Richard ll with David Tennant) and a member of the National Trust so we can have ‘free’ days out now we are retired (they have some lovely restaurants, and a lot of cracking second-hand bookshops!). No way am I joining anything else at the moment.

Having said that, the cinema does broadcast the NTLive productions. Just last week we saw People and we have tickets for The Audience later, and membership does give a discount…..? No. On reflection not worth it.

Last week my Latin teacher, Neil Treble, came to the Museum to give a talk on Cicero, Man of Action or Ditherer. Part of his argument was, of course, the conspiracy of Cataline, shown graphically in this painting. But also his inability to judge people very well, underestimating ‘the boy’ Octavian, and really getting under the skin of Mark Antony. This was his final undoing. The talk was very entertaining, Neil is a clever speaker, hitting just the right note. It is just a shame that the audience was not larger. (See the beginning of this blog. Weather was atrocious, we were lucky to get an audience at all!) However, he made enough of a good impression to be asked back again later in the year. Memo to self – make sure it’s the height of summer!

One last plea to the gods. Jupiter in particular. Please can we have at least a glimmer of spring. I’m not asking for full-blown summer, even though we are now into BST, just a little spring sunshine. And lose the bitter cold winds – please! I want to be able to go out of my house without looking like the Michelin man. I want to be able to go to the golf club and play the course, not practice on the range. I want the dogs to come in from their walks without treading mud everywhere. Is that too much to ask?

 

 

February was a funny month

 According to the BBC weather forecaster this morning March 1st is the first day of spring. Looking out of the window it seems very doubtful. It’s as dull and overcast as it was yesterday, which was, presumably, the last day of winter. For me it is the nadir of the year. I find the short, miserable days of winter difficult to say the very least. And February is definitely the worst month. Winter has already taken it’s toll. It’s weeks and weeks since the, possible, high of Christmas. New Year’s resolutions have either gone by the board, or become part of life. Being retired, there is no necessity to force oneself out of the door to go to work. The golf course has been closed on and off, and , when it is open, the weather makes golf uncomfortable and undesirable. So there is little incentive to leave the house unless there is shopping to do. The result has been that February has been spent mainly indoors! Depressing and not healthy.It hasn’t even been a profitable time. The house doesn’t look any cleaner, and I haven’t read anything particularly productive.

There have been a couple of exceptions. The Roman Museum had another of it’s series of talks about various aspects of ancient Rome. The speaker was Judith Affleck, the guiding light behind my Latin lessons, who is used to teaching a roomful of grammar school boys. She coped magnificently with the audience of grey haired museum volunteers, talking about the influence of women on the emperors. She focused on the most famous two, Livia and Agrippina the Younger, mother of Nero. The picture shows a depiction of the latter appearing to ‘crown’ her son emperor, an amount of power unheard of for women at the time. That was certainly worth making the effort to go out in the cold! Agrippina is one of my favourite ancient women. Boy, did she have balls!

To be fair, I did get out on to the golf course – once! Just nine holes, on my own as a practice, with Paul carrying my bag – bless him! This is the sixteenth hole at Stratford Oaks Golf Club, but not on a miserable day in February! I put this in to remind me what is to come, hopefully, later in the year.

One other good thing last month. Referring back to last month’s blog, I did actually get my tickets for Richard ll. It took 40 minutes to get two tickets,and I had to sit and watch tickets disappear before my eyes as I tried to transfer them to my basket, but I got them. David Tennant, you had better be worth it! For anyone who isn’t a Member of the RST there doesn’t seem much hope of getting anything except those tickets available on the day of performance.

Now that spring is officially here, perhaps things will improve. It’s not so much the basic weather, it’s one’s attitude to it. In February it’s so long since autumn, and so long until spring. Now March is actually here, and it is OFFICIALLY spring, optimism can begin to creep in. There have been walks at Ragley Hall during February, for the snowdrops, but it’s been far too miserable, wet and cold. Perhaps this months, to see the daffodils, will be a better option. Whatever, it must be better than February, surely.

It’s all David Tennant’s fault!

Living so close to Stratford upon Avon we see a lot of the Royal Shakespeare Company productions. I think I have seen almost the entire Shakespeare repertoire in the year’s I’ve lived here. And my absolute favourite play is, without any doubt, Richard ll. The first time I took much notice of it was when I was studying with the Open University a course called Culture and Belief in 16th century Europe. It was the set book for the Shakespeare section. By sheer good luck that was the year the RSC produced the play at The Other Place, with Sam West in the title role.

So when the programme came out for the winter 2013 season, Greg Doran’s first as Director, I was thrilled to see the play amongst the delights in store. The problems I could see, however, rather tempered my delight. The lead role was to be taken by David Tennant, and the play was only in the repertoire for a month. Now I am an Associate Member of the RSC, which gives me, for a moderate fee, a few weeks advance booking. Not as much as a full member, but usually enough. However, knowing from bitter experience the popularity of the aforesaid Mr Tennant, I was not sure if this was going to be enough this time, even though performances don’t start until next October. So I decided to check. I rang the Membership Hotline, only to be told that they were unable to answer because of ‘unprecedented’ demand! So I left a message, and, joy of joys, a delightful person rang me back within the next couple of hours. I was right, memberships were being taken out in vast numbers! Now Full Members can book on-line from 11th February, and Associate Members from 4th March. With a very limited number of performances the chances of any decent seats being left are remote. What might be left are the ‘limited view’ ones, or the Superseats at vast cost.  The price of these is considerably more than the difference in the types of membership. So I bit the bullet and upgraded. David, your performance had better be worth it! In the meantime note to self. Reminder on Calendar to remember to go in and book at 9 o’clock on the morning of 11th February, otherwise it will have all been in vain. The Christmas production this year is to be Wendy and Peter Pan. Must check if grandchildren would like to see it. You can’t go to it without a child in tow!

At least the weather is trying to look up. We had quite a lot of snow, though not as much as other areas of the country. And so far we seem to have managed to avoid flooding with the thaw. This is a decided improvement on other years when the High Street was a river! There has been a huge amount of work put in over the last couple of years, and all credit goes to the people who got it right!                                                                      

Not sure what the bunting was for, but Alcester seems to erect it for any possible occasion!

But the snow did have it’s effect. Last week I was unable to get into Stratford for my Latin class! This week was fine, but it is amazing how much difference missing a week can have. Good news though, the proposed group trip to Rome in October seems to be a runner! The idea is to stay in either a monastery or a convent because they do inexpensive, 3 star equivalent, B & B. Not sure how I will fit in there,but we shall see! Now to persuade Paul to come as well!